How to tell the difference, so you can get the right relief.
Your nose is clogged and you’re sneezing like mad. With the change of season warming the air, you might assume you’ve caught a cold. But have you? Spring can bring on allergies, since pollen is plentiful at this time of year. Fall can also bring allergies, since pollen from ragweed and other weeds is plentiful at this time of year. And as the warmer spring temperatures call us outdoors, or cooler fall temperatures drive us indoors, mold, and dust also become issues. Considering that cold and allergy symptoms can overlap, your diagnosis could go either way.
Why does distinguishing cold from flu matter? “If you know what you have, you won’t take medications that you don’t need, that aren’t effective, or that might even make your symptoms worse,” says Teresa Hauguel, PhD, an expert with the National Institutes of Health on infectious diseases that affect breathing. One survey found that more than half of people who try to self-diagnose get it wrong, believing they have allergies when they actually have a more serious sinus infection (sinusitis).
Getting the wrong treatment can have repercussions. A bad cold can morph into a bacterial infection. Uncontrolled allergies can run down your body, leaving you more vulnerable to illness.
Here’s how to tell the difference between a cold and allergies, and tips to tame your symptoms, no matter which condition caused them.
Cold vs. Allergies
Colds and allergies stem from separate causes. You catch a cold when a sick person sneezes or coughs in your vicinity and the virus finds its way into your system via your nose or mouth. The immune system attack your body launches against these miniature invaders triggers symptoms like congestion, sneezing, and watery eyes.
Allergy symptoms result from an immune system misfire. Your body’s line of defense mistakenly identifies pollen, dust, or mold as germs, leading to the release of histamine and other chemicals that clog your nose and make your eyes run. Once either process starts, it can be hard to tell what triggered it.
Allergies are often mistaken for colds because the symptoms are almost indistinguishable. “Allergy symptoms come on slowly, so the patient doesn’t know if he or she is getting sick or not,” says Meena Kakarala, MD, an internal medicine physician at Piedmont Physicians Group in Atlanta, Ga.
Yet there are some subtle differences between cold and flu symptoms. “Most allergy-related nasal secretions are clear or white, not discolored. The patient may have a sore throat from postnasal drip, but typically nothing beyond that,” Kakarala says. A tissue full of green or yellow gook when you blow your nose and a raw throat are signs you’re likely dealing with a cold. Fever and body aches are another clear giveaway that a virus is behind your symptoms.
Duration can also be a clue to the cause. A cold might put you out of commission for a couple of seven to 10 days, but allergies will stick around for weeks or months, as long as you’re exposed to the trigger.
Getting the right care
Both cold and allergy symptoms respond to over-the-counter antihistamines and decongestants, which (respectively) block the action of histamine to relieve congestion, and shrink swollen blood vessels in the nose. (Avoid antihistamines that can cause drowsiness.) With allergies, you’ll want to start on these medicines as early as possible in the season to keep your symptoms at bay. Colds may require some extra care, which can include pain relievers, along with plenty of rest.
If you’re not sure which condition you have, see your primary care provider. Then, if allergies are to blame, get advice from an allergist, who can pinpoint your trigger so you can avoid it. The doctor might also suggest immunotherapy, a treatment that exposes you to gradually increasing doses of the allergen to desensitize you to it. Once you’ve figured out that you have allergies and what triggers them, you can cut out the guesswork next spring.
February 21, 2017
Janet O’Dell, RN