Pilates. Feldenkrais. Alexander. NIA. Exercise classes with self-explanatory names like “Ab Crunch” can’t match the mystique of these programs, each with its own loyal following. Your class could become a community, if you’re as lucky as the dozen or so women in my neighborhood who have taken Pilates with Jeanette for decades. (One or two men do show up, too.) Besides conversation, what’s actually going on?
Something a little different in each program and class, as I’ve found myself. Here’s our quick primer:
Pilates. Joseph Pilates began developing his floor exercises while in an internment camp for German-born residents in England during World War I. After he came to New York City in the 1920s, the city’s professional dancers discovered that his methods helped them recover from injuries.
Today, Pilates studios contain a variety of devices that aren’t quite like the machines you see elsewhere. In a “matt” class that you might find in an all-purpose gym, you’ll work lying or sitting on the floor or standing up.
Pilates strengthens the abdominal and other muscles through a combination of precise movement and controlled breathing. Teachers recommend these classes for people of any age, even if you have lost strength through inactivity, illness, or injury. Pilates can also be challenging enough for dancers and athletes.
A number of studies have looked at whether Pilates is especially helpful for people with chronic low back pain; an overview concluded that it helped, but not more than other forms of exercise. In my case, I acquired impressive abs after several months of twice-a-week classes, but still had my chronic neck and shoulder pain.
Many gyms offer Pilates; you’ll have to look harder to find classes in Feldenkrais, Alexander, or NIA, but they’re common in bigger American cities, though not necessarily at your regular gym.
Feldenkrais. Moshe Feldenkrais, an electrical engineer and physicist, suffered multiple knee injuries that made him unable to walk. He unsuccessfully tried many treatment before he experimented on his own, performing minute variations in his movements that led to his recovery and unique body of exercises. You can opt for private sessions with a teacher or work in a class, mostly on the floor.
The goal won’t be to burn calories, stretch, build muscles, or train your willpower. Instead, you’ll focus on recognizing the sensations of unneeded muscular effort. You may have a habit of tightening your neck as you lift your arm, for example, or clenching your stomach muscles as you walk, and over time cause yourself unnecessary fatigue or pain. In a Feldenkrais class or session, you’ll be instructed to move in unusual ways and explore subtle differences. The teacher will avoid telling you what’s ideal and instead encourage your own discoveries. Feldenkrais is slower and gentler than Pilates — and I found it fascinating. The intense attention required cleared my mind when I was anxious and I also felt much freer of pain, after several months of weekly classes and then weekly one-on-one sessions. Although my results didn’t stick I still do some of the exercises I learned, and they help.
Although the studies are small and can’t be considered conclusive, some research supports Feldenkrais for Parkinson’s, neck pain, osteoarthritis, improving balance in seniors, and increasing body acceptance in people with eating disorders.
Alexander. Fredrick Matthias Alexander, an actor born in 1869 in Australia, found that he would lose his voice during performances and be unable to continue. Because the medical advice he received didn’t help, he began experimenting with ways to hold his head and neck. Like Moshe Feldenkrais, he came to believe that harmful habitual movements caused a variety of problems and began teaching other performers how to identify and avoid them.
Alexander had his students work in front of a mirror, observing themselves as they went through the motions of sitting, standing, and lying while maintaining the best position of the head, neck, and spine. You might also receive one-on-one treatment lying on a table or sitting in a chair. The teacher will give you specific instructions on improving your posture.
I’ve tried this, too, in one-on-one sessions, and ended up discouraged, though that’s probably my own fault.
Strong studies suggest taking this approach to treat back pain, and there’s some reason to try it for Parkinson’s and improving balance. In one study following 579 back pain patients for a year, six one-on-one lessons were nearly as effective as 24 in treating back pain, and did more than massage.
NIA. These cardio-dance sessions, created by a San Francisco team in 1983, combine 52 simple moves from the world of modern dance and martial arts. Dance barefoot to music from around the world, and adapt the moves to your ability. You’ll dance behind the teacher, following her, or students may dance with each other, in partners or as a group. I find it a fun, mild workout that also strengthens the arms.
May 07, 2015
Janet O’Dell, RN